Why Engineered Wide Plank Flooring Became the Standard in Modern Homes
Today, engineered wide plank flooring is the predominant choice. It appeals to manufacturers because it can be mass-produced and installed over modern subfloors, like slab construction, without the specialized knowledge that solid wood floors require. Engineered floors have made wide plank aesthetics accessible to a broader audience, but solid wood remains unmatched in character and craftsmanship.
A 40-Year Perspective on Wide Plank Craftsmanship and Tradition
Having been in wide plank floor manufacturing for more than 40 years, I’ve seen the slow shift toward engineered planks. My father, Dale Carlisle, founded Carlisle Restoration Lumber to procure wide boards primarily for historical renovations in early American homes in New England. When I took the reins, I focused on promoting the beauty of center-cut wide plank floors from the finest trees—just as was done historically. This approach emphasized the natural life of the tree and the unique character that solid wood can offer.
Center-Cut Wide Planks: Preserving the Tree’s Natural Character
Most manufacturers cut the “best” parts of the tree out before milling, leaving behind narrow strip flooring. To honor the full beauty of the wood, I had to advocate for mills to leave boards long and wide, allowing the life of the tree—its mineral streaks, knots, and natural color variation—to shine through in every plank.
When Engineered Flooring Makes Sense, and Why William & Henry Builds It Differently
That said, engineered flooring has its place. It allows wide plank aesthetics to reach new heights in modern construction and can be installed in ways that solid wood cannot. However, most engineered floors have a relatively thin top layer, allowing only one or two refinishes. William & Henry engineered floors are different—we use a thicker top layer, giving a more authentic solid wood feel and allowing three to four refinishes over the life of the floor. This means you can enjoy the benefits of engineered flooring without sacrificing longevity or character.
Choosing the Floor That Matches Your Space, Expectations, and Style
At William & Henry, we enjoy crafting both types of flooring. While there are differences, a solid floor retains the authenticity, depth, and life of the wood in a way engineered floors can only approximate. For those who care about true wide plank character, a solid floor remains the ultimate choice—but we also provide engineered options that honor the same beauty, craftsmanship, and longevity that define our brand.